top of page

Why Does Your Mediumship Fall Apart Right Before You Level Up?

Writer: Hannah Macintyre
Hannah Macintyre
6 days ago
7 min read

Updated: 1 day ago

I've seen it happen not once, not twice, but hundreds of times. A student decides, mentally, that they're ready. Ready to practise with real sitters. Ready to start charging. Ready to really step up their business and put themselves in front of people. And the moment that decision is made, their mediumship falls apart.

I know this because it happened to me too, long before I understood it was happening to everybody.

Why does mediumship go wrong right before it's about to expand?

When you first start out, you don't believe you can really do this. You're hopeful but nervous, just experimenting, just playing, not at all sure you're capable of it. So when you get a hit, it's electric. You can't believe it landed. Over time, though, we acclimatise. The thing that once blew your socks off stops registering as anything special. You say "I feel like I've got your dad here," they confirm it, and a year in you're barely blinking. That's natural. But I think it plays a bigger part in what happens next than we give it credit for.

Mediumship, in its optimum state, is a surrender. I hate this theory, but it's true. The hardest thing to do is surrender, to sit in front of someone expecting the right loved one with the right evidence, and not get tangled up in that expectation.

The moment we start setting ourselves little targets, "once I can do this, I'll be ready to read for the public", we've stopped surrendering. A target isn't a surrender. There's a difference between hoping you'll get there one day and needing to hit a benchmark before you'll let yourself move forward. And I think, sometimes, Spirit are also trying to help us grow before we take that step, which can feel exactly like going backwards. Suddenly you're getting more no's, pushing into areas you've never worked in before, and it feels congested and uncomfortable. It isn't your mediumship collapsing. It's expanding into somewhere new, and new is always going to feel creaky.

Why do we stop surrendering the moment it matters?

Because we're human. When it's practice, when there's no expectation, when nobody's watching or the only person watching is smiling and supportive, we allow. The moment money enters, or visibility enters, identity and persona start creeping in, and it all becomes problematic.

Here's a question worth sitting with: why is it that professional mediums, generally, once they reach a certain level, stop talking about how hard it was to learn? Why don't they admit when they get things wrong? We're in a culture of sharing our highlight reels and hiding the bits we got wrong, which builds an expectation that isn't real. Every professional and every learning medium I've ever spoken to has moments of struggle. We just don't talk about it, so when other people struggle, they think something is uniquely wrong with them.

"Needing your mediumship to be good kills the state that makes it good, and that's the problem." — Hannah Macintyre

What happens when we start "getting ready" to go pro

It doesn't have to mean you've already started charging. It can be as small as deciding that in six months you'll start. The moment that decision lands, you start holding your mediumship up to a standard shaped by what you imagine it should look like once money is involved. That's not a surrender anymore. That's gripping, proving, forcing, chasing, monitoring, analysing. And the irony of trying so hard to make it something is that we often stop it being anything at all.

We do need standards in mediumship. A limp reading that could apply to anybody, giving the sitter nothing, is genuinely one of the worst things you can offer someone. But there's a difference between holding a standard and gripping so tightly that you strangle the very thing that made your mediumship good in the first place.

What I learned from running Risky Business on Spirit Social

I'd been watching mediums online and noticing they only ever share their best bits. So I asked myself: could I show my best moments even in a sea of things that were slightly wonkier? Could I actually do that? A voice in my head immediately said, "you're not getting it right now, and if you try to force it, it'll all go to shit."

So I created a session on Spirit Social called Risky Business, advertised honestly as pushing into new areas of evidence, where we expected no's, expected problems, expected spirits that couldn't be taken, expected evidence that might be creaky or unrecognisable. The whole point was to push the limitations of what we could do, in a space that felt safe enough to let that happen. Spirit Social was perfect for it, our own community, good energy, people who genuinely want to learn and grow with Spirit.

And the most incredible thing happened. My mediumship was superb, straight away. I'm not saying I didn't get no's. I did. But I also got some genuinely excellent evidence, right out of my comfort zone, good enough to clip and share. Watching my mentorship colleagues do the same, expanding, shifting, exploring in real time, was one of the most joyful things I've experienced in a long while. We've already booked another one for the end of July.

Why one "no" can undo thirty "yeses"

There's a particular pattern I see again and again. A sitter will say yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, right through a reading, and then hit one thing they say no to. By the end, they'll fixate on that single no and tell you they don't know what to make of the whole reading, even with thirty confirmed yeses sitting right there. That's human nature, and it happens to me too. But it's exactly why the fear of getting something wrong in front of a paying sitter can be enough to make your mediumship wobbly, long before you've actually started charging anyone.

Are you allowing Spirit to say no?

When you decide to start practising with real sitters, it can genuinely feel like Spirit has vanished. Where have you gone? Why does it feel like you've left?

They haven't left. They're waiting for you to step up and do what you said you were going to do. And every spirit that comes through in a practice reading can't automatically be the one the sitter is hoping for. Sometimes Spirit bring through exactly who's best for your learning and your expansion, not who the sitter is sitting there waiting to hear from. Are you confident enough to hold that? Are you sure you can't take this person, or are you assuming you can't because you're nervous?

Delivery matters as much as the message

I once worked with a student whose mediumship was genuinely great, but her delivery was so apologetic and hesitant that nobody could buy into what she was saying. I told her plainly, "you've got to look like you know what you're doing." She said, "oh, not this again," and I never saw her again. That still feels devastating to me, because the mediumship itself was there. It was only the delivery undermining it.

Why it feels like a video game

I keep coming back to the gym as an analogy, but this time think of it like a video game. Sonic the Hedgehog, if you will.

"The next level energy is there before you complete that level, so you've got to start the level... you've got to go through all of those zones, and you've got to learn, and you've got to understand." — Hannah Macintyre

You pick up new skills as you go, but you have to learn which buttons to press and what they actually do. It's the same with mediumship. Expanding into a new area means that area starts at a lighter weight, an unfolding, still-learning energy, even while the rest of your mediumship is solid. That doesn't mean Spirit don't want you to go pro. It means you're expanding your evidence into new territory, and new territory always feels unsteady before it feels natural.

The comparison trap

Once the analysis creeps in, it sucks the joy out of what you're already achieving. Your bright, sparkly mediumship starts to feel dull. That's usually the exact moment people start scrolling other mediums online and thinking, "I can't do that." Most of what you're seeing is a clip, not a standard. A moment of brilliance, not a full reading, not the process behind it.

"Spirit is a flow. Energy builds. Magic happens when we let go, not when we hold on." — Hannah Macintyre

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does my mediumship feel worse right before I'm ready to go pro?

It's usually not your ability disappearing, it's the shift from surrender into control. The moment you start setting benchmarks or worrying about money and visibility, you stop allowing and start gripping, and that grip is what makes the mediumship feel like it's falling apart.

Is it normal to get more no's when I start practising with real sitters?

Yes. Spirit often bring through who's best for your growth and learning in that moment, not necessarily who the sitter is expecting. Getting more no's while pushing into new areas is a sign of expansion, not failure.

Why do professional mediums make it look so easy?

Because most of what gets shared online is the highlight reel, a clip of a brilliant moment rather than the full standard of practice, struggle included. Almost every medium, professional or developing, goes through periods of real difficulty. It just rarely gets talked about.

How do I stop analysing my mediumship so much?

Try creating a genuinely safe space to practise where getting things wrong is expected and welcomed, rather than something to avoid. Removing the pressure to be "good enough" tends to bring the surrender back.

Does struggling before a big step mean Spirit don't want me to take it?

No. It usually means the opposite. It's an energetic shift into new territory, not a sign that your path isn't supposed to unfold.

Key Takeaways

  • Mediumship falls apart right before expansion because we shift from surrender into control, usually the moment money, visibility or identity enters the picture.

  • Setting benchmarks ("once I can do this, I'll be ready") isn't a surrender, it's a test, and testing kills the flow.

  • Getting more no's while pushing into new territory is a sign of growth, not failure.

  • Professional mediums rarely show their struggles publicly, which creates an unrealistic standard that isn't actually real for anyone.

  • Delivery matters as much as content. Hesitant, apologetic delivery can undermine genuinely strong evidence.

  • Comparing yourself to a clip online is comparing yourself to someone's best moment, not their whole process.

About Hannah

Hannah Macintyre is an evidential medium, author and spiritual teacher who hosts the Mediumship Matters podcast. Her book, You Are a Medium (You Just Don't Know It Yet), explores how mediumship really works from an evidential perspective. She teaches with curiosity and honesty rather than rigid rules or false certainty.

Want to keep developing in a space built for exactly this?

If this episode resonated, my monthly Spirit Circles are a place to practise, push your edges and grow your mediumship alongside people who genuinely understand what that takes. You can also listen to the full episode wherever you get your podcasts.

bottom of page