top of page

Is It Spirit or Your Imagination? How to Tell the Difference

Writer: Hannah Macintyre
Hannah Macintyre
Apr 18, 2025
3 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

One of the biggest questions I get asked, and one we all ask ourselves at some point, is this: is it spirit, or am I just making it up?

If you’ve ever sat there wondering whether you’re having a genuine connection or just an overactive imagination, you are absolutely not alone. If mediums got a pound every time we doubted ourselves, we’d all be on a beach with a cocktail instead of clutching a notepad wondering whether that was spirit or our brain going rogue again.

It’s supposed to feel like you’re making it up

Mediumship is rarely like the films. No booming voices, no Victorian figures pointing dramatically at the family silver. Most of the time it’s so subtle you’ll dismiss it as imagination, at least at first. Do you know what it still feels like for me, after years of doing this? Like I’m sitting in a room making it all up. The difference is that when I share what I’m getting, it lands for the person in front of me in ways I couldn’t possibly have known.

There’s a reason it feels that way. Mediumship doesn’t happen to you, it happens through you. Information comes through your own mind, your own thoughts, your own interpretation. For most mediums, seeing happens in the mind’s eye, and hearing sounds like your own inner voice, just carrying something you didn’t consciously build. When nobody explains that, people assume they’re failing. They’re not. That’s what it’s like for almost all of us.

I also think spirit is far closer than we’ve been taught to believe, woven into our reality rather than watching from somewhere far away. If we felt them as vividly as we feel the people in the room, it would overwhelm us. The subtlety isn’t a limitation. It’s protection.

How imagination and spirit tend to differ

Imagination feels controlled. Spirit feels spontaneous. When you’re imagining, you’re steering. Spirit tends to drop things in from nowhere. You suddenly think of a yellow teapot when you’ve never cared about teapots in your life, and your sitter bursts into tears because their nan had a yellow teapot she treasured.

Imagination is predictable. Spirit surprises you. “Her grandad probably liked gardening because she looks outdoorsy” is you. Blurting out “Did your grandad collect rubber ducks?” and hearing “He had hundreds!” is not something you’d invent.

Spirit is a whisper, not a shout. People expect it to be loud and overwhelming. It’s the opposite. It’s quiet and easy to miss, like background music that you only notice once you actually start listening.

And spirit takes the path of least resistance. If you pick up feelings more easily than pictures, they’ll work through feelings. Because it flows so naturally, it won’t feel dramatic, which, annoyingly, makes you doubt it even more.

Doubt doesn’t go away, and that’s fine

I wish I could tell you there’s a magic point where you never question your connection again. There isn’t. Experienced mediums still have days where they wonder whether they’re doing it right. The difference is they’ve got used to the doubt and don’t let it stop them. Honestly, I’d be more worried if you never questioned yourself, because doubt is part of discernment and a sign you care about doing this honestly.

You also don’t need to decide whether it’s all real right now. You can notice your experiences, learn how this works and keep practising without committing to a conclusion. Clarity comes gradually.

What actually builds trust

Work with other people. This is the turning point. Until you receive information you couldn’t possibly know and watch it land, it’s very hard to separate imagination from spirit. There’s no shortcut around this stage. Practice is what builds discernment.

Say it anyway. Stop waiting for the whole message before you open your mouth. Say what you’ve got, “I feel a man here, he’s giving me a sense of humour, I’m drawn to the name John”, and more will come. It’s like turning on a tap. Sit there waiting for certainty and you’ll block yourself.

Keep a record. Write down what you get, including the bits that seem silly. Over time you’ll see patterns and hits that prove it wasn’t your imagination after all.

So, is it spirit or your imagination? Sometimes it’s both. Spirit uses your mind, your thoughts and your feelings as their canvas. Your imagination isn’t your enemy. It’s part of the connection. Embrace the wobble, doubt and all.

If you’d like to keep practising with real people and real feedback, that’s exactly what Spirit Social is for. And if doubt is the thing that keeps stopping you, my book Overcoming Doubt in Mediumship was written for exactly that.

 
 
bottom of page